Consider This: 2024 elections

Some of these elections can be categorized as “free and fair,” meaning that citizens can stand for election and campaign fairly, allowing the voters to choose their preferred candidate on an even playing field. In authoritarian countries, like Russia and Venezuela, citizens can vote, but the contest is neither free nor fair, with opposition leaders in jail and campaigning, freedom of speech and association all severely restricted. Finally, we have a third classification, hybrid democracies, which are functioning democracies with weaknesses in their electoral systems and their governance.

The predictability of election outcomes

Some election outcomes are predictable because they are held in authoritarian countries, while others are predictable because one of the contenders has an exceptionally big lead over a weak, fragmented opposition.

However, investors will be focused on the elections held in the countries that are most relevant to their investment portfolios, and those countries where a binary election outcome has the potential to generate investment profits or losses, depending on the capital markets’ assessment of a country’s future economic prospects.

In Exhibit 2, we have highlighted in blue the territories where our clients have the most interest in for investment reasons. India will hold the biggest election in terms of number of voters and it will be the longest-lasting, over months, while Indonesia will hold the largest election held on a single day. As the world’s largest economy, the US presidential election in November is clearly very important because of the impact the next president could have globally.

In Taiwan, the recent elections resulted in a Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) president, but a legislature dominated by the opposition Kuomintang (KMT) and Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) parties. With no party gaining a majority, President William Lai will have to negotiate with the opposition parties to execute on policy. The two high-profile policies he campaigned on are the phasing out of nuclear power (with a determined drive to boost solar and wind power) and the lengthening of military service from four months to a full year for young Taiwanese. Investors have already driven up the valuations of wind-power-related companies on the Taiwan Stock Exchange and will anticipate a continued campaign for Taiwan to open access to more export markets around the world.

Investment implications from other elections

Indonesia: On February 14, approximately 205 million voters¹ will select the next president and the representatives in the legislature (in Indonesia, serving members of the armed forces and police are not allowed to vote). The polls indicate ex-General Prabowo Subianto is in the lead with a 20-point gap, but may not reach the 50% threshold, triggering a second round against either Anies Baswedan (ex-governor of Jakarta) or Ganjar Pranowo (ex-governor of Central Java). It is difficult to predict the winner, as over 60%² of eligible voters are under 40 years of age, meaning that climate change, education, corruption and jobs are key issues. For investors, it seems likely that Indonesia will be able to continue to balance relationships with China and the United States, while being well placed to build a key position in the new architecture of global supply chains, based around its critical mineral resources. The key variation looks to be the degree of protectionism around the natural resources sector, depending on the winning candidate.

India: Around 945 million³ registered voters in India will have the opportunity to elect their representatives in the Lok Sabah. The latest polls suggest that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s personal popularity will sweep him back into power at the next elections, although his party may have a diminished majority in parliament. The opposition has formed a 26-party coalition under the acronym INDIA, but it lacks a unifying leader to rival Modi. This third term of a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led government is expected to continue pushing the “Make in India” agenda, while investment in infrastructure is a necessity. India will likely continue to block Chinese investment in electric vehicles, preferring to subsidize domestic production. The 2024 budget will show increasing tax revenues, and investors anticipate a reduction in interest rates post elections. There may be some progress with the implementation of new labor laws, which could attract foreign direct investment. International investors have high expectations; post-election policy execution is key.

European Union (EU): In June, around 450 million citizens⁴ of the 27 member states of the EU will hold elections for the European Parliament. Historically it has been dominated by center parties—the European Peoples’ Party (EPP) and the Socialists and Democrats (S&D). This time, the polls suggest a more “right-wing” looking EU. Some might think that this is a problem, but the reality is that it depends very much on the composition of the “right wing.” The moderate European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) are very anti-Russia and immigration and reject a federal EU, but do work with center parties. The newer and rising Identity and Democracy (I&D) grouping (including Italy’s Lega, France’s National Rally and Germany’s AfD) is more sympathetic to Russia and skeptical on Brussels and is less likely to be constructive in policymaking. In any case, investors should expect a closer alignment with the United States on China, with potentially more restrictions to inward investment, continued momentum for the “Green Transition” and a greater focus on border control and defense, leading to closer alignment with NATO.

United Kingdom: Although the government has until January 2025 to call elections, most observers expect elections in November or December 2024. The polls suggest that after 13 years, the Conservative Party is trailing by around 20 points, suggesting that a change is coming. A Labour government would probably lead to more productive relations with the EU, although there is no suggestion of a move to reverse Brexit. For investors, the conundrum remains to gauge the United Kingdom’s undoubted attractions, including low market valuations, with a productivity challenge at a time of stretched government finances and a tough economic outlook.

United States: It is hard to overstate the global importance of the presidential elections. The two-party system produces binary outcomes, but experience demonstrates that majorities in Congress and the Senate are key to any president’s ability to execute on their agenda. From available information, investors can expect policies to boost American manufacturing and reshoring to the (United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA), continued obstacles to trade with China and a reluctance to commit to direct intervention in foreign wars. It seems that a Republican president may force closer cooperation between the United Kingdom and the EU and a move by Asian countries to hedge their position with regard to China. 

The risks include AI and election disinformation

Perhaps ominously, this record year of elections around the world is also the first time that generative artificial intelligence (AI) tools such as Chat GPT and Midjourney became widely available—as well as the technology for “deepfakes,” where high-profile people can be digitally cloned for use in realistic videos. The implications for election campaigns are extremely concerning, as these new technologies could multiply and intensify attempts at spreading misinformation to influence electoral outcomes.

The threat of weaponized misinformation and already-prevalent geopolitical tensions suggests that it might be prudent to stay informed and knowledgeable on the issues, the dynamics of each election and the potential implications for policy direction. We at Franklin Templeton Institute can help.